Suppose I hand you a closed box and ask, “What’s in it?” There’s really only one good answer: “I don’t know. Let’s look inside.”
A bad answer would be, “A puppy.” You don’t know that. You just wanted a puppy.
That’s the difference between reading the Bible well and reading it poorly. Good Bible study finds out what’s in the box. Bad Bible study decides what’s in the box before you even open it. Scholars have fancy names for these. Exegesis means drawing the meaning out of the text. Eisegesis means reading your own ideas into it. You can forget the fancy names if you like. Just remember the box.
So how do you look inside? You ask questions. Six of them, to be exact: who, what, when, where, why, and how. Think of them as detective questions, and if you only take one thing away from this series, take these. They work on every passage, every time.
A quick word before we go on: good Bible study follows a sequence. First you observe what the text says, then you interpret what it means, and only then do you apply it. The detective questions belong to step one, observation. If “observe, interpret, apply” is new to you, the overview is a quick read and will help this one click.
Who Is Talking, and Who Are They Talking To?
I once saw Luke 4:7 on a daily affirmation calendar. You can get it on a baby onesie too. It’s adorable:
“If you, then, will worship me, it will all be yours.” (Luke 4:7, ESV)
Doesn’t that make you feel good? Worship and get stuff. Who could argue with that?
Well, ask the first detective question. Who is talking? The devil. He’s tempting Jesus in the wilderness. So you probably don’t want to put that one on your wedding invitations. Definitely don’t get this as a tattoo!
Asking who is speaking, and who is being spoken to, saves you from a lot of trouble. Is Paul writing to a healthy church or a messy church? He wrote plenty to both sorts. Is God speaking to a single person in a single moment, like his promise of land to Abraham? Then we need to be careful about claiming it as our own. Reading someone else’s mail is one thing; cashing their checks is another matter. We’ll sort out which promises belong to whom when we get to interpretation, but it starts here, with simply noticing who’s who.
What Is the Subject? (If You Only Get One Right, Get This One)
If I had to pick a favorite, it would be the “what” question. What is the subject or topic being discussed? What comes before this verse, and what comes after it?
Here’s a favorite small group verse:
“For where two or three are gathered in my name, there am I among them.” (Matthew 18:20, ESV)
It’s usually read as a promise for small groups. Some folks even treat it as the minimum size of a church. But wait a second. I was praying the other day all by myself. Golly. I hope the Lord didn’t leave the room.
Back up a few verses and look at the “what.” Jesus begins with, “If your brother sins against you, go and tell him his fault, between you and him alone” (Matthew 18:15). Then he talks about bringing one or two others along “that every charge may be established by the evidence of two or three witnesses,” and then telling it to the church. The subject is church discipline. The “two or three” are witnesses in a hard and painful process, and Jesus promises to stand with them in it.
That’s still a beautiful promise. It’s just a different one than the postcard version.
Here’s a simple way to think about it. Suppose a passage talks about raising your kids, raising your kids, raising your kids, then money, then raising your kids again. What’s the money part about? It may involve money, but it’s mostly about your kids. You can’t lift the money verse out and build your business plan on it.
Anybody can quote Scripture. The devil does it in Luke 4. When someone quotes a verse and something in you says, “That doesn’t sound right,” go look at the “what” of the passage. You’ll get a pretty quick read on whether the person is drawing meaning out of the text or just making their case.
When and Where Is This Happening?
Time and place sound like boring details. They’re often the details that change everything.
I once saw Psalm 51:10 on a lovely plaque at a retreat center: “Create in me a clean heart, O God, and renew a right spirit within me.” It was really pretty. I even took a picture.
Now look at the little heading above Psalm 51. It tells you when David wrote it: after Nathan the prophet confronted him about his sin with Bathsheba. Suddenly that plaque verse isn’t a nice thought about fresh starts. It’s the cry of a man who committed adultery, covered it up with murder, and got caught. Knowing when doesn’t make the verse less beautiful. It makes it more honest.
The “where” question works the same way. In Acts 16:6-10, Paul and his companions are forbidden by the Holy Spirit to preach in Asia, so they head north toward Bithynia, and the Spirit of Jesus won’t let them go there either. If you read it without a map, it’s just a list of strange place names. Look at a map, and you realize Paul is walking along the border between two regions for days and days. He wants to spread the gospel, and the Holy Spirit keeps saying, “Nope. Not there. Keep walking.” Then comes the vision of the man from Macedonia, and the Gospel crosses into Europe.
Once you see the “where,” you go, “Oh. The Holy Spirit really wanted him to end up somewhere specific.” That’s the kind of thing a quick read will never show you.
Why? (This One Comes With an Asterisk)
Put a little asterisk next to the “why” question, because most of the time you shouldn’t try to answer it during observation.
Remember, at this stage we’re just gathering data. Usually the text doesn’t tell us why something happened, and if we start guessing, we’re already interpreting. That comes later.
Sometimes, though, the author tells you outright. John does this. He says his Gospel was written “so that you may believe that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God, and that by believing you may have life in his name” (John 20:31). Mark does it too. After Jesus says that what goes into a person “enters not his heart but his stomach,” Mark adds a note: “Thus he declared all foods clean” (Mark 7:19). Why did Jesus say it? Mark just told you.
When the text states the why, write it down. It’s gold. When it doesn’t, leave the space blank for now. A blank space is honest. A guess dressed up as an observation is a dangerous thing.
How Are People Responding?
The last question watches the people in the passage. How do they react? What do they do?
Revelation is full of strange imagery, but the “how” question cuts right through it. In Revelation 5, when the Lamb takes the scroll, the four living creatures and the twenty-four elders fall down before him. Then every creature in heaven and on earth sings, “Worthy is the Lamb who was slain.” That’s how they respond to Jesus. They worship him.
Now watch what happens when John tries to worship an angel near the end of the book:
“I fell down to worship at the feet of the angel who showed them to me, but he said to me, ‘You must not do that! I am a fellow servant with you and your brothers the prophets, and with those who keep the words of this book. Worship God.’” (Revelation 22:8-9, ESV)
The angel’s response is basically, “Whoa, whoa, don’t do that.” The Lamb receives worship. The angel refuses it. Just by noticing how people respond, you’ve learned something important about who Jesus is, and you didn’t need a single commentary to see it.
Here’s the line I want you to remember: We want to find out what’s in the box, not put what we want in the box.
See What’s There, Not What Isn’t
The detective questions have a sneaky side benefit. They train you to notice what the text doesn’t say.
How many wise men visited Jesus? Most of us say three, because that’s how many are in the nativity set. The Bible doesn’t give a number. It mentions three gifts but that doesn’t automatically mean 3 people. I’m not going to get bent out of shape about a person’s head count for the wise men. Still, it’s good practice to just stick with what is explicitly revealed in the Text. The stuff you can touch with your finger.
Try It Yourself
Read Jonah 1:1-6. Grab a notebook and work through the six questions:
Who is in the passage? Who speaks, and who doesn’t?
What does God tell Jonah to do, and what does Jonah do instead?
Where does God send Jonah, and where does Jonah go? Look them up on a map. (They are not in the same direction.)
Why does God send Jonah? Does the text say? If so, write it down. If not, leave it blank.
How do the sailors respond to the storm? How does Jonah respond?
Bonus: count how many times Jonah goes “down” in this short passage. Then ask yourself whether you’ve ever noticed that before.
Why Your Church Needs These Questions
Most people in your church have heard verses quoted out of context so often that they don’t even notice anymore. Matthew 18:20 gets printed on small group flyers. Luke 4:7 shows up on a calendar. A preacher on TV quotes a dozen verses in a row, and it sure sounds biblical.
The detective questions give ordinary church members a way to check. No Greek, no Hebrew, no seminary library. Just who, what, when, where, why, and how. When a small group leader learns to ask “What is the subject here?” before asking “What’s the significance here?”, the whole conversation changes.
These questions travel well too. A pastor in a rural village with nothing but a Bible can use exactly the same six questions as someone with a full study library. That’s one reason they sit at the very beginning of BTCP training around the world.
None of this is reserved for scholars. Normal people with an open Bible and a little practice can learn to read Scripture well. That’s exactly what BTCP classes are for.
This article is part of a series. See the full series: How to Study the Bible
This article is adapted from my teaching in Bible Study Methods and Rules of Interpretation, the first course in the BTCP curriculum. You can look through a sample of the course manual here.
Free Printable: Bible Study Methods at a Glance
A summary of the three steps of Bible study, the six detective questions, and the rules of interpretation, plus a practice sheet you can use with any passage. Print it, share it, and keep it in your Bible.
Download the free printable (PDF)
Bring This Training to Your Church
BTCP helps churches host in-person classes that work through the whole curriculum, one course at a time, right in your own building. Pastors, elders, small group leaders, and members learn side by side, with the Bible open on the table.
If you’re a pastor, elder, or missionary who wants to train others, start with a free Interest Meeting. It’s a relaxed conversation about how a class could work in your setting.
Register for a free Interest Meeting
Looking for a class to join? Tell us where you are, and we’ll help you find one. Contact us here.
Matt Hulgan is the Executive Director of BTCP and has taught its curriculum since 2013. His favorite part of the work is watching someone realize they can study the Bible for themselves. He lives in metro Atlanta with his wife, their three kids, and too many pets.